Trade credit insurance protects businesses from unpaid invoices due to customer insolvency, financial distress, or political risks. Here’s what you need to know about underwriting factors and coverage:
- Key Risks Assessed: Non-payment, insolvency, and political risks.
- Coverage: Typically 75%-90% of invoice value; premiums range from 0.05%-0.6% of insured sales.
- Underwriting Focus:
- Buyer Financial Health: Credit scores, liquidity, and debt levels.
- Industry and Location Risks: Political instability or volatile industries.
- Customer Payment History: Patterns of late payments or disputes.
- Revenue Concentration: Diversified customer base preferred.
- Credit Management: Strong internal practices reduce risk.
- Credit Limits: Tailored based on buyer’s risk profile, updated through real-time monitoring.
- Exclusions: Pre-existing debts, fraud, and force majeure events.
AI and real-time tools now enhance risk evaluation, ensuring accurate pricing and better coverage. This insurance not only safeguards cash flow but also supports business growth by mitigating financial risks.
TCI Week 2023 – Artificial Intelligence in Trade Credit Insurance
Main Underwriting Criteria for Trade Credit Insurance
When it comes to trade credit insurance, underwriters rely on several crucial factors to evaluate risk levels and decide whether to provide coverage. These factors help shape policy terms, set credit limits, and calculate premiums, ensuring protection for both the insurer and the policyholder. Each element builds on the previous one, creating a detailed picture to guide underwriting decisions.
Buyer Financial Strength and Credit History
The financial health of a buyer is at the heart of any underwriting decision. Underwriters dig into financial statements to assess liquidity, profitability, and debt levels, often using key metrics like the current ratio, debt-to-equity ratio, and working capital. They also use credit ratings from internal models and external agencies such as S&P, Moody’s, Fitch, and D&B DRS Score to measure creditworthiness. Insurers maintain vast databases with millions of company profiles or directly request financial records from buyers. This cross-referencing helps identify any potential red flags. Additionally, external factors like industry trends and geographic conditions play a role in refining the overall risk assessment.
Industry and Location Risks
Not all industries or regions are created equal when it comes to risk. Some sectors face economic volatility or cyclical challenges, while specific geographic areas may grapple with political instability, regulatory hurdles, or even climate-related risks. These factors directly impact underwriting decisions and premium rates. For instance, companies operating in politically unstable or environmentally sensitive regions often face higher premiums. A real-world example involves a U.S.-based pharmaceutical company whose overseas subsidiary struggled with payment delays from a government entity for infectious disease test kits. In this case, AIG Trade Credit used global data to assess the risk and support credit extensions.
Customer Payment Patterns and Track Record
A buyer’s payment history is another critical piece of the puzzle. Underwriters examine how consistently payments are made, the frequency of late payments, and any history of disputes. This analysis is vital because one in five business bankruptcies among small-to-medium enterprises can be traced back to customers defaulting on invoices. By studying payment patterns, insurers can better predict and minimize the risk of bad debt, helping businesses maintain healthier cash flow.
Customer Portfolio Concentration
The way revenue is distributed across a company’s customer base also impacts its risk profile. A high concentration of sales to a single customer – where one buyer accounts for 20% or more of revenue – can signal potential trouble. Since accounts receivable often make up a significant portion of business assets and cash flow issues contribute to 82% of business failures, underwriters generally prefer diversified customer portfolios. Most insurers recommend that no single customer account for more than 15% of total revenue.
Payment Terms and Credit Management Practices
The credit terms a business extends to its customers and its internal credit management practices are key to understanding risk exposure. While offering extended payment terms can boost sales, it also increases the risk of non-payment. Effective credit management involves thoroughly researching new customers using tools like credit bureaus, Chambers of Commerce, and bank references. Regularly reviewing the creditworthiness of existing clients is equally important. To ensure accurate risk evaluation, businesses typically provide detailed customer lists, recent aging reports, and concise applications.
"It is the actionable plan you use to guard against bad debts, late payments or unpaid invoices. It helps your business’s cash flow forecast and improves performance."
Setting Credit Limits and Monitoring Risk
Once risks are assessed, underwriters move on to setting credit limits and putting tracking systems in place. This ongoing process ensures that coverage stays in sync with actual risk levels, helping to prevent potential losses. By revisiting earlier assessments, insurers can maintain coverage that matches current conditions.
How Credit Limits Are Set for Each Buyer
Credit limits are a key part of trade credit insurance, defining the maximum amount an insurer will cover for each buyer. These limits are determined by evaluating the buyer’s financial strength alongside probability of default (PD) models. Factors like financial history, income stability, and debt levels play a significant role in tailoring limits to each buyer’s specific risk profile.
The process starts with a deep dive into both historical and current financial data. Insurers rely on a mix of internal risk models and external sources, such as Dun & Bradstreet and Experian, to get a full picture. This precision is especially important in the U.S., which represents $1 billion of the global $7.0 billion trade credit insurance market.
Continuous Risk Monitoring Systems
Credit limits aren’t static – they need to evolve as buyer risks change. While the initial limits offer protection against immediate risks, ongoing monitoring ensures those limits remain accurate over time. Advanced systems now use real-time data and regular updates to adjust limits automatically and flag potential issues. For example, these tools can track payment behaviors and trigger additional credit reviews when necessary.
Automation powered by AI and machine learning has become a game-changer. These technologies predict potential blocked orders and simplify financial data collection. Insurers like Coface provide 24/7 monitoring and adjust coverage as needed throughout the policy term. One notable success story involves a multinational chemical supplier that reduced default losses by 20% while reinforcing its market position through custom trade credit insurance and continuous monitoring.
These systems also integrate with external credit agencies to pull in critical data automatically. This ensures that credit limits stay up to date, reflecting any shifts in financial conditions.
sbb-itb-b840488
Policy Coverage Structure and Key Features
Understanding what your policy includes and excludes is essential for making well-informed decisions about protecting your business. Trade credit insurance policies can be tailored to fit your specific needs, providing a flexible framework that aligns with your business risks and goals. By combining risk assessment and credit limit setting, the policy structure outlines the financial safeguards available to you. This foundation helps clarify the details of the coverage features.
Types of Risks Covered and Exclusions
Trade credit insurance typically protects against three main types of risks: commercial risks, insolvency, and political risks. However, policies also come with exclusions. Common exclusions include:
- Insolvency of your own company
- Certain political risks not explicitly covered
- Force majeure events
- Uninsured buyers
- Pre-existing debts
- Fraud or misrepresentation
- Country-specific risks
To maximize your coverage, it’s important to keep an updated list of buyers and ensure each is properly insured under your policy. For businesses operating in politically or economically unstable regions, standard coverage may not be enough. In such cases, you might need to purchase additional coverage or limit your exposure. Notably, global insolvency rates increased by 10% in 2023, highlighting the importance of these protections.
Coverage Percentages and Deductible Amounts
Most policies cover between 75% and 95% of losses, with 90% being a common figure. For instance, on a $100,000 invoice, you could expect coverage of roughly $90,000. Premiums usually range from 0.05% to 0.6% of turnover, with 0.2% being a typical rate. To put it simply, this means paying about $1.00 to $1.50 per $1,000 of sales. For a business generating $10 million in annual sales, premiums would amount to approximately $10,000 to $15,000 annually.
Deductibles work similarly to other insurance types – you bear part of the loss before the policy kicks in. The deductible amount depends on factors like your risk profile, the creditworthiness of your customers, and the terms negotiated with your insurer. Businesses working with higher-risk customers or industries often face higher premiums, lower coverage percentages, or steeper deductibles. This is especially critical considering that, on average, 40% of a business’s assets are tied up in unpaid invoices. Policies can also be adjusted to address specific business needs beyond standard metrics.
Policy Customization Options
Today’s trade credit insurance policies offer a range of customization options to suit different industries and challenges. These include specialized coverage for manufacturing risks, political risks, disputed claims, or even Directors & Officers liability protection. Aligning your policy with your credit control systems and invoicing practices ensures a seamless fit with your business operations.
Underwriting Standards and Regulatory Requirements
Trade credit insurance underwriting demands detailed documentation and strict compliance with regulations, all grounded in thorough risk assessment. These elements form the backbone of the underwriting process, as outlined below.
Required Documentation and Risk Assessment
A complete buyers list – including company name, address, VAT number, and country – is essential for evaluating risk. This information serves as the starting point for underwriters to assess potential exposures.
Underwriters closely examine your sales ledger, customer profiles, and risk tolerance to determine coverage and premiums. This detailed documentation directly influences pricing and the establishment of risk limits. To further refine their evaluations, underwriters often use credit reports and scoring services to track the financial health of your customers.
When filing claims, it’s crucial to provide unpaid invoices, evidence of default, and proof of collection efforts.
Key policy documents include the policy specimen, declarations, endorsements, and buyer credit limits. The policy specimen specifies covered risks, requirements for insured receivables, exclusions, claim filing periods, and settlement timelines. Meanwhile, the declaration page summarizes critical terms such as the sales basis, premium rate, insured retention, policy limits, and reporting and claim filing obligations.
These documentation practices form the foundation of the regulatory framework guiding trade credit insurance underwriting.
US Regulatory Compliance Requirements
In the United States, compliance with Basel III has tightened capital requirements, raising the common equity minimum from 2% to 4.5% and Tier 1 capital from 4% to 6%. These changes have directly influenced underwriting practices.
The broader economic impact of credit insurance is evident in industry data. A 2020 survey by ITFA and IACPM revealed that $135 billion in credit insurance coverage supported $346 billion in loans to the real economy. Additionally, between 2007 and 2020, 97.73% of all credit insurance claims were fully paid.
Industry leaders regularly advocate for greater regulatory recognition of credit insurance’s value. Richard Wulff, Executive Director of ICISA, highlights its importance:
"At a time of economic difficulty, unlocking bank financing to the real economy is an important policy question governments must address. Recognising the protection that highly-capitalised and well-regulated insurers deliver to banks for precisely this purpose could be an easy win, benefiting businesses around the world in the long run."
Regulatory frameworks also address the prevention of trade-based financial crime. These regulations mandate banks to perform verification checks and monitor transactions, ensuring compliance in increasingly digitized cross-border trade.
Marilyn Blattner-Hoyle of Swiss Re, Global Head of Trade Finance, Trade Credit & Working Capital Solutions, underscores the potential of the insurance and banking partnership:
"US regulators have a win-win opportunity here to further the Basel financial stability aims with a proven ecosystem – the insurance and bank partnership in the credit space. This ecosystem has the potential to create trade and help companies. We are convinced that the insurance industry will continue to be a safe and diversifying risk partner."
Experts Hernan Mayol and Som-lok Leung also stress the need for regulatory alignment:
"The proposed implementation of the Basel Accords should recognise the suitability of credit insurance as an eligible risk mitigant under the capital rules. This will not only advance the goals of the Basel Accords, but also place US banks on equal footing with non-US banks."
These regulatory requirements shape underwriting standards, compelling insurers to maintain rigorous documentation, conduct detailed risk assessments, and ensure continuous compliance throughout the policy term.
Key Points for Trade Credit Insurance Underwriting
When it comes to trade credit insurance, insurers focus heavily on financial and credit data. This focus ensures that coverage aligns with the risks involved, making it crucial to provide accurate and thorough information.
As Kirk Elken, Co-founder of Securitas Global Risk Solutions, explains:
"Approved buyer credit limits are key. Financial and credit information drive the underwriting process."
To help underwriters make precise credit risk assessments, gather all relevant buyer details, including the company name, address, VAT number, and country. This level of detail ensures a smoother evaluation process.
Another important piece of the puzzle is working with experienced brokers. Their expertise can be invaluable, especially since underwriters may interpret and act on information differently depending on how current and complete it is.
Managing approved credit limits also requires careful oversight. If you exceed these limits, you take on the extra risk yourself. This makes it essential to evaluate any additional credit you extend to customers cautiously.
Enhancing your company’s risk profile can also make a big difference. Tools like AI-driven early warning systems and strong cybersecurity measures can improve your standing with underwriters, potentially leading to better terms.
The stakes are high – default or insolvency is responsible for 25% of corporate bankruptcies. This is why underwriters take a detailed approach when reviewing applications.
To streamline the underwriting process, ensure your documentation is accurate and submitted promptly. Partnering with seasoned brokers can help you navigate these requirements more effectively.
For additional guidance, CreditInsurance.com offers resources to help businesses meet underwriting standards. These tools not only protect against financial risks but also support growth by enabling increased credit lines and better financing options.
FAQs
How do underwriters set credit limits for buyers in trade credit insurance?
Underwriters play a crucial role in determining credit limits for buyers under trade credit insurance. They do this by thoroughly assessing the financial health and risk profile of each buyer. Key factors like creditworthiness, payment history, and overall financial stability are carefully reviewed during the process.
Typically, businesses provide insurers with a list of customers they want to insure, along with the credit limits they’re requesting. Based on this data, insurers evaluate the potential risks and assign coverage limits accordingly. For instance, a large, well-established company might qualify for a $1,000,000 credit limit, while a smaller business may be approved for $50,000. This approach helps businesses strike a balance between protecting themselves from financial exposure and offering credit to their customers confidently.
What factors determine the cost of trade credit insurance premiums?
The cost of trade credit insurance premiums hinges on several important factors. One of the biggest considerations is the creditworthiness of your customers. If your customers are financially unstable or deemed high-risk, insurers are likely to charge higher premiums to offset the potential for claims.
Your industry sector also plays a role. Businesses in industries that are more prone to fluctuations or economic volatility often face steeper insurance costs.
Insurers will also take a close look at your company’s trading history and loss history. If you have a solid record of successful transactions with few or no claims, you may benefit from lower premiums. On the other hand, frequent losses or claims can work against you. Similarly, the geographic regions where you conduct business matter – operating in politically or economically unstable areas can increase perceived risks, which may drive up your premiums.
The structure of your policy is another key factor. For example, opting for higher deductibles can help reduce your premium costs. Insurers also evaluate your annual revenue and the credit terms you offer to your trade partners when determining the final price of coverage. These elements collectively shape the overall cost of your trade credit insurance.
What steps can businesses take to maximize their trade credit insurance coverage and reduce exclusions?
To make the most of your trade credit insurance policy, start by sharing precise and thorough details about your customers during the underwriting process. Insurers use this information – like payment history and financial stability – to evaluate risk and outline your coverage terms.
Take the time to thoroughly review your policy so you’re clear on any exclusions or conditions that might apply. If something doesn’t align with your business’s needs, consider negotiating adjustments with your insurer. Keeping your insurer informed about any changes in your customers’ circumstances is another way to ensure your coverage stays relevant and effective.
By staying engaged and maintaining consistent communication with your insurer, you can help safeguard your business from financial challenges, such as non-payment or customer insolvency.
